08-24-2015, 09:47 AM
unsuccessful.
the clues to Straia and KJavi were good, there was one good clue to Chamber (assuming killdare mentioned all clues since they weren't in your reveal), but the clues for Erebor were vague.
story is far too vague of a clue; there are many characters with names from stories
'we all have a great potential, we should not settle for the unpaved path' is a clue to the Unfinished Tales, which is a clue to the story of the Quest for Erebor, and therefore not a direct clue to the horse's actual name
unpaved path is not a synonym for mountain, nor is an unpaved path necessarily remote or lonely.
suggestions for the future: clues for the actual meaning of the name (ie lonely or mountain or synonyms of those), describing the meaning of the name (ie what is erebor - a dwarf kingdom, etc)
the clues to Straia and KJavi were good, there was one good clue to Chamber (assuming killdare mentioned all clues since they weren't in your reveal), but the clues for Erebor were vague.
story is far too vague of a clue; there are many characters with names from stories
'we all have a great potential, we should not settle for the unpaved path' is a clue to the Unfinished Tales, which is a clue to the story of the Quest for Erebor, and therefore not a direct clue to the horse's actual name
unpaved path is not a synonym for mountain, nor is an unpaved path necessarily remote or lonely.
suggestions for the future: clues for the actual meaning of the name (ie lonely or mountain or synonyms of those), describing the meaning of the name (ie what is erebor - a dwarf kingdom, etc)